A Carbon Fee
Can Speed Deployment


Developing innovate technologies is key to solving climate change. But we also need to ensure new, low-carbon technologies are rolled out across the economy.

History shows that deployment of new
innovations isn’t always quick or automatic.

Take the invention of the automobile: it took 30 years to replace
the horse in the U.S. transportation system.

Evolution of horse & buggy to modern car

Without some sort of a market pull, even the most
promising climate solutions might stay on the sidelines,
slowing our efforts to address climate change.

The government is a large investor in research and development that has the potential to create innovative breakthroughs for climate and energy:

In 2019, the U.S. Department of Energy spent $14 billion on R&D.

Total federal spending on non-health R&D topped $60 billion that year, including both direct spending and tax breaks for companies’ own R&D efforts.

The private sector invests more than 4x as much every year.


To get a return on this investment for the
environment and the economy, we need to see the
best technologies brought to market–and fast.


So, how do we ensure climate technologies
quickly find their place in the economy?

There are essentialy three policy tools:

1

Subsidies to cut the cost of technologies

2

Regulations to mandate the use of technologies

3

An economy-wide carbon price to create a market incentive for technologies

Of these three tools, an economy-wide carbon
fee is the only one that can achieve the rapid uptake of carbon-
efficient technologies at scale, across sectors.

A carbon fee…

Dollar sign

Offers a price advantage
for carbon-efficient
solutions that is stable
and predictable

binoculars icon

Doesn’t depend
on future
government action
to be effective

up arrog icon with leafs icon

Stokes demand
for low-carbon
solutions across the
economy, not just
in certain sectors

carbon price - regulations - subsides chart

A carbon price is the best tool we have for
expediting the deployment of low-carbon technologies

How Carbon Dividends
Helps Manufacturers


U.S. climate policy should reward our
manufacturers for doing the right thing.

The Problem:

Under today’s trade rules, U.S. manufacturers get no credit for their lower carbon operations compared to many overseas competitors.

Currently, the U.S. imports 75% of its goods from less carbon-efficient countries.

When low-cost goods made with high emissions come into our market, it undercuts U.S. manufacturers who have made investments to cut emissions. For example, when steel rebar is produced in America to reinforce concrete, it typically generates less than a quarter of the carbon emissions per ton than rebar manufactured elsewhere in the world.

Yet our steelmakers are forced to compete against many producers overseas who operate with fewer environmental standards. Our manufacturers shouldn’t be penalized for being so clean.

The Solution:

America already has a significant carbon advantage: it produces goods with far fewer emissions than its major trading partners. We just need to unlock it.

A border carbon adjustment (BCA) charges the same domestic U.S. carbon fee on imports at the border, so U.S. manufacturers operate on a level playing field.

U.S. manufacturers receive a rebate for any carbon fees they paid when they export goods out of the country.

The U.S. economy is 44% more carbon-efficient than the world average. It is 3x more carbon-efficient than that of China and nearly 4x as efficient as India. We should get credit for it.

The Benefits:

A BCA backed by an economy-wide carbon fee rewards U.S. manufacturers for their efficiency and gives them the incentive to build on it. 

America’s carbon advantage extends to a range of U.S. sectors. 

When U.S. manufactures outcompete less efficient global producers, they grow and create jobs.

This means…

icon factory and leaf

More goods made in America with fewer emissions

icon money

More good-paying jobs that put money in Americans’ pockets

icon flag

A stronger economy

We invite you to learn more

Stimulating Carbon
Capture and Storage


The carbon dividends plan will boost the incentive to capture and store carbon emissions from power plants and industrial facilities, an activity that is widely seen as critical for meeting climate goals. 

HERE’S HOW IT WORKS:

factory stack CO2 icon

Absent a federal incentive, it is not economic for companies to capture and store the carbon emissions from their industrial processes. They would lose money by doing so.

To scale up this key climate technology, an existing federal program offers incentives, known as section 45Q tax credits, to businesses that capture and store carbon emissions underground. A business gets up to $50 for each ton of CO2 that it sequesters. 

factory stack tax credit icon

The carbon dividends plan introduces a carbon price at $43 per ton of CO2 that rises 5% every year. Activities that qualify for the 45Q tax credit would also qualify for a rebate under the carbon dividends plan.

factory stack tax credit and rebate icon

By combining these incentives, we can accelerate the deployment and commercialization of carbon capture. This technology holds great promise for being exported around the world–to the benefit of the U.S. economy and the climate.

A carbon fee rebate provides an enduring and predictable incentive structure that will improve the long-term prospects for this climate-enhancing activity.

As the carbon fee rises each year, the incentive to capture and store carbon emissions also grows.

Eventually, the carbon fee could replace the tax credit altogether, establishing a permanent incentive that doesn’t need to be reauthorized by Congress.

For example, the combined incentive (45Q tax credit + carbon fee rebate) could be capped at $110 per ton of CO2. Once the carbon fee exceeds $110 per ton of CO2, businesses would still get rebated the full amount of the carbon fee. 

A Rising Incentive to Capture and Sequester Carbon
(45Q Tax Credit + Carbon Price)

carbon price and tax credit chart

The Case for a
Bipartisan Solution


Why a climate policy needs broad support.

icon corinthian columns

Policies that are supported by members of both parties are far more likely to pass and to last. And they can achieve more in the long run simply by standing the test of time.

icon blue leaf

A stable policy, supported by members of both parties, offers the certainty and predictability that investors, entrepreneurs, and consumers need to make clean energy investments with confidence.

blue icon world

Climate change demands a global solution. A climate policy that shifts with each new administration or Congress hampers America’s ability to lead the world towards lasting climate progress.

Americans want a bipartisan solution.

When Americans have faced great challenges in the past, we have rallied around solutions. The scale and speed of climate change requires that Americans come together in support of a lasting and effective policy.

A consensus climate solution is within our reach. Polls show that broad majorities of the public, including voters of both parties, want federal action to address climate change.

8 to 1

Voters say they are more concerned about climate change


6 to 1

Voters want any national climate solution to be bipartisan


Source: Morning Consult

Why carbon dividends is the
bipartisan climate solution

icon factory

A carbon fee harnesses market forces to quickly slash emissions across the entire economy. It’s a free market approach with a dramatic environmental impact.

icon money bill

Quarterly dividends payments reward all Americans for reducing emissions. The lowest-earning 8 out of 10 households, on average, come out financially ahead with this plan.

icon hard hat

Border carbon adjustments offer an effective strategy for getting other major economies to follow our lead, while creating an incentive for investments in job growth here in the United States.

icon handshake

No other climate policy has united such a broad set of stakeholders or holds such strong bipartisan appeal.

Who supports the
carbon dividends plan:

4 to 1
icon 3 people

Voters Overall


2 to 1
icon republican elephant

Republicans


3 to 1
icon young person wearing glasses

Republicans Under 40


Source: Morning Consult

How Carbon Dividends
Helps Families


A carbon fee is unique among climate policy approaches in that it generates revenue that can be returned to citizens, investing all Americans in a clean energy future.

With the carbon dividends plan:

All the revenue netted from the carbon fee is returned to Americans in quarterly payments. A family of four will receive about $2,000 a year.

Nationwide, household disposable income increases.

The vast majority of families come out financially ahead with this plan, collecting more in dividends than they pay out in increased energy costs.

Lower-income households come out most ahead, seeing a larger proportional boost in their spending power.

Impact By State

Hover over your state to find out how this plan will affect you:

Nationally: 8 in 10 households,
on average, come out ahead
with this plan

Source: Oxford Economics

Why is it on average?

While every person gets the same size dividend, the net benefit varies by household due to differences in household size, energy use, and other factors. It is not set in stone. Families can increase their benefit over the long run by investing in ways to shrink their carbon footprint. Or they can use it for other things they value. The dividend is theirs to spend as they choose.

Nationwide: 8 in 10 Deciles Come Out Ahead

Nationwide 8 in 10 Deciles graphic change in household disposable income

Source: Oxford Economics

The Environmental Ambition of
the Carbon Dividends Plan


Nothing would do more to accelerate innovation and invest all citizens in a clean energy future than an economy-wide carbon fee with corresponding dividends for the American people.

The Climate Leadership Council’s proposed economy-wide carbon price, starting at $43 per ton, would cut U.S. carbon emissions in half by 2035 all on its own. When paired with other commonly discussed policies like efficiency standards and nature-based investments, it can cut carbon emissions by 50% or more by 2030.

PROJECTED EMISSIONS IMPACT OF THE
COUNCIL’S $43/TON CARBON FEE

Chart of projected emissions 1990-2034

Fast: This policy will achieve steep emissions cuts in its first year. The faster we cut emissions, the more we slow climate change and prevent damage to ecosystems and human health.

Reliable: People can feel confident that this policy will achieve its emissions targets. The carbon fee is backed up by an emissions assurance mechanism that will kick in to increase the fee faster if emissions goals are not met.

Global: This plan reaches beyond America’s shores to hold other countries accountable for their emissions. Through a system of border carbon adjustments, it leverages the American consumer to promote clean energy around the world.

Amplifies all other climate policies: Whether you want to promote electric vehicles, carbon capture and sequestration, battery storage, renewables, nuclear, or any other low-carbon solution, a price on carbon will make it easier and cheaper.

Helps communities: This plan will create healthier communities as we protect the climate. It will cut some of the most common air pollutants by as much as half.

Criteria Air Pollutant Projections from Power, Transport
and Industry (% Change from 2019)

chart of Carbon Fees affect on pollutants

Be part of the solution


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Climate Leadership Council, 1900 M St, Washington, DC, 20036, http://clcouncil.org. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact